I don't usually do-over

I'm not one for making pages, only to disassemble and remake them again.  Heaven knows no one has time for that.  I made this page and was satisfied with the results:

But when I saw this adorable Playground product line from Echo Park, I knew I'd have to reconsider. In about 7 minutes, I had the new page made.

In the meantime, my original page had been posted and chosen on ClubCK as an entry for a contest to be published in an upcoming magazine.  Thanks to all your votes it won!

Now, this month, in Creating Keepsakes October 2011, you can find it on page 42 of this magazine. It's hitting newstands now!

So even though it's a published layout, and I'm deeply honored that it was chosen, it's into the recycle bin; and I'm printing the new version for my book.

Which one do you like better?